IJ study archive

Scene 064: hal orin phone joi suicide

Scene
64
Pages
242–258
When
5 Nov YDAU (2009) (dateline, p. 242)
Where
Hal's Subdorm C room at E.T.A. (clipping toenails into a distant wastebasket); Orin on the phone from a deep-tissue therapist's bathroom in the Superstition Mountains above Mesa-Scottsdale AZin: E.T.A. (Enfield Tennis Academy) › E.T.A. subdormitories · Phoenix-area Arizona (also)
POV
Hal (3rd person, but rendered almost entirely as unattributed dialogue)

Connects to (editorial cuts & payoffs, 11)

Summary

A sixteen-page telephone call, nearly all dialogue: Orin — prodded by "Helen" Steeply's soft-profile questions and spooked by burly wheelchaired men seemingly tailing him — calls Hal for the first time in years to extract the family facts he skipped the funeral for. Against Hal's running commentary on his can't-miss toenail-clipping streak (the "magic" of The Zone and the superstition of not examining it), the brothers circle and finally enter the suicide: JOI's head in a rigged rotisserie microwave, the drilled door-hole packed with foil, the Wild Turkey with a gift bow, no note — and Hal, thirteen, the one who found him. Hal then narrates his grief-therapy ordeal: unable to "deliver the goods" to a relentless grief-pro, he researches the therapist's own professional literature on Lyle's advice and performs a textbook breakdown — climaxing in the (true) confession that his first reaction at the door had been "That something smelled delicious!" The scene is the book's fullest account of JOI's death and of Hal's signature pathology: flawless performance of feeling in place of feeling.

What to notice

Sixteen pages of nearly unattributed dialogue, and the exposition works like fencing: each brother extracting what he wants while conceding as little feeling as possible — Orin needs the family facts he skipped the funeral for; Hal parries with toenail-clipping commentary and burial trivia. Notice the plant: ghost-lore enters the call one page before the dead father does — "The sated ghost cannot see secret things." — folklore about managing the dead, recited by two sons about to manage theirs. The suicide's horror is carried entirely by deadpan precision (the hyper-exact kitchen geography of the rotisserie microwave, the potato physics), and its worst image is pure reaction shot: the field pathologist who chalked lines around the shoes, gestured at the walls, and threw up. The grief-therapy story is the book's parable of performance: Hal researches the therapist's own literature and fakes a textbook breakdown so well that it contains his only genuine confession — "That something smelled delicious!" — fraudulent affect that happens to be true, grief-therapy passed without grief being felt. Notice that the call itself repeats the pattern: sixteen pages of connection conducted through shtick, ending on a copyedit ("And the word is asphyxiated").

Beats — page-by-page

  • pp. 242-243: Dateline 5 Nov YDAU; the transparent phone under Hal's bedding (n.82: Hal and Orin as slobs in psychic opposition to the Moms's compulsive cleaning; lax prorector Corbett Thorp never inspects); Orin's sewage-commission gag opening; the can't-miss clipping streak and the Zone/superstition riff ("Coordinated as God"; deLint's "playing out of your head," Loach's "The Zone").
  • pp. 243-244: Hal's burial-ritual digressions, deployed as deflection: the Ahts of Vancouver pouring virgin blood into embalmed ancestors — "The sated ghost cannot see secret things" — as prophylaxis against schizophrenia; rural Papineau-region Québecers drilling a hole down through the coffin lid "to let out the soul, if it wants out." Ghost-lore seeded a page before the dead father enters the call (and the coffin drill-hole rhymes darkly with the hole JOI drilled in the microwave door).
  • pp. 244-245: "I think I'm being followed… by handicapped people": the post-office Subject, three burly wheelchair men in an hour, one in a domino-mask mired in trailer-park gravel; Hal teases ("very shy fans") and runs his trailer-decor quiz (velvet leopard painting, doilies, Smoke-B-Gone ashtray — Orin confirms most).
  • pp. 245-247: Why Orin actually called: Moment magazine's "Helen" is doing a soft profile shaping up as "some sort of memorial to the Stork as patriarch"; the team front office wants it; Orin needs to know what he's not saying before he doesn't say it; Hal's list of the forbidden topics is a one-sentence index of the whole novel ("Himself and annulation… Himself killing himself, you and Joelle, Himself and Joelle, the Moms and C.T.…," p. 247).
  • pp. 247-251: The facts, extracted in ellipsis-pocked stichomythia: C.T. moved into HmH days before; it was the rotisserie microwave, not the oven; JOI drilled a head-sized hole in the door and packed the gap with wadded foil; the bow-tied Wild Turkey bottle; no note; Hal — having lost to Freer and come to HmH "around 1630" with emergency laundry — found him, and went for the Moms, then C.T., then Lyle, but ran into Schtitt, "irreproachably brisk and efficient."
  • pp. 249-250: Timeline friction: Orin insists Joelle said JOI had quit drinking in January (her condition for appearing in "what he was doing"); Hal recounts the month underground in the post-production closet, the McLean's detox, the three-day film-related trip, and that he never saw him after April First's lunch.
  • pp. 251-252: The potato physics: have you ever baked a potato in a microwave?; the B.P.D. (n.83) field pathologist's "over two sticks of TNT," ten seconds tops, "Hence the need to reconstruct the scene."
  • p. 253: the field pathologist who drew the chalk lines around Himself's shoes (not a body outline), gestured at the kitchen walls, and threw up.
  • pp. 252-254: Grief-therapy: Rusk and the Moms shunt Hal to a top grief-pro up Comm. Ave. within hours; the meaty red therapist with demonic eyebrows, sneeze-crusted mustache, and never-visible hands; Hal reads the entire grief section (Kübler-Ross, Kastenbaum and Kastenbaum, Neeld's 352 pages of "sheer goo," n.84) and presents textbook-perfect symptoms — which fail, because they're a performance (the exam-in-Hindi nightmare figure, p. 253); the face-in-the-floor nightmares begin (p. 253); he drops weight, loses again to Freer and then to Coyle, gets B's on quizzes, fears he will "flunk[ing] grief-therapy" — his own coinage — (pp. 253-254).
  • pp. 254-255: Lyle's key insight (delivered in the weight room over Leaves of Grass, his own Whitman-period grieving): stop studying grief, study grief-professionals — "empathize with the grief-therapist"; Hal cabs to a library "still in my towel."
  • pp. 255-256: The delivery: Hal presents with rage, foul language, and library-derived terms (validate, process, toxic guilt), builds to the Abrupt Pause — and screams the truth: coming in hungry at the door, his first reaction to the smell had been "That something smelled delicious!"
  • pp. 256-257: Absolution "with seven minutes left in the session"; the handshake reveal — the massive authority figure's hands "no bigger than a four-year-old girl's"; Hal's hysterics in the men's room, "stamping my feet and beating my head against first one side of the stall and then the other in hysterical mirth."
  • pp. 257-258: Coda: Hal's sudden swerve into nails-as-vestigial-talons and the fetal "bladdery sac" — Orin asks "Did this fuck you up…?"; final trailer-decor confirmation (the afghan throw); "And the word is asphyxiated"; Hal holds the phone to the foot, "his expression terrifically intense."

Themes in this scene

  • Fathers and Sons: the dead father examined forensically by the two sons who couldn't mourn him — Orin who skipped the funeral, Hal who found the body; even Lyle grieves Himself more legibly than they do.
  • Family and Hamlet: the ghost-father, the uncle moved in upstairs days before the death, the mother's "guilt and antiguilt operations" (p. 253) — Orin says it outright: Hamlet's plot, in a phone call.
  • Communication and Solipsism: a sixteen-page connection conducted through shtick; Hal's truest disclosure ("smelled delicious") was itself produced strategically to satisfy an authority figure — performance all the way down, with the panic-stricken boy unreachable inside it.
  • Irony and Sincerity: the grief-therapy arc is the book's parable of fraudulent affect that happens to be true: Hal fakes a breakdown so well it contains his only genuine confession, and "passes" grief without grieving.
  • Surveillance and Disguise: Steeply's Helen persona (the profile pretext) and the A.F.R.'s wheelchaired watchers converge on Orin in the same call — both intelligence operations mistaken for nuisances.
  • The Body and Tennis: the can't-miss clipping streak as a comic seminar on The Zone — flow, superstition, and the self-consciousness that kills it ("Talking about it's broken the spell," p. 248), Hal's tennis psyche in miniature.
  • Ghosts and Wraiths: the call is framed by burial-lore about managing the dead — the Aht "sated ghost cannot see secret things" and the Papineau coffin-hole "to let out the soul" (pp. 243-244) — while the brothers perform exactly that management on their own unmourned father; Schtitt's "revenant" vocabulary attaches to Hal the next day (scene 065).
  • Film and Optics: JOI's last months are reconstructed as a filmography mystery — the post-production closet, the three-day "film-related" trip with or without equipment, Joelle's condition for appearing "in what he was doing," and Hal's belief the final edit "turned out so bad he didn't want it released" (pp. 249-250, 253) — the call is a primary (and unreliable) source on the Entertainment's making.
  • Dreams: the grief-therapy account seeds two of Hal's dream-systems — "This was when the nightmares started," the face-in-the-floor recalled and dated to the post-suicide spring (pp. 253-254), and the failed-goods panic rendered as the nightmare "where you prepare immaculately and then... all the exam questions are in Hindi" (p. 253).
  • Memory and Forgetting: the call is a memory operation — Orin extracting the family's stored version of the death he skipped ("who... keeps his memory alive, verbally, the most now"), Hal performing recall he cannot feel ("Found by one Harold James Incandenza, thirteen going on really old," p. 249); the family's memory of JOI is maintained, audited, and traded — everything but felt.

Connections — backward & forward

Backward

  • Answers Joelle's bathroom musings of two scenes back (scene 062, p. 231: how would you rig a microwave to run with the door open?) with the engineering specifics (pp. 248, 250-251) — the two people JOI made things for, asking the same question in adjacent scenes.
  • Hal's list of unaskable topics (p. 247) doubles as the novel's index.
  • Lyle paying counsel-for-sweat (pp. 254-255) extends scene 055; Schtitt as the right authority figure (p. 250) deepens the Schtitt-as-true-father motif (fathers-sons).
  • Dating note: "four years 216 days" (p. 249) vs. 1 Apr YTSDB ruling — same class of internal inconsistency as scene 013's "over four years"; cited as written per the archive's policy.
  • "The little blind Illinois kid Thorp thought so well of" in Moment (p. 246): Carlisle links him to Dymphna, Hal's scheduled WhataBurger opponent (scene 003) — an inference, not stated.
  • Carlisle flags a continuity friction we should carry: Hal had his first nightmare away from home his first night in the dorms (p. 62, scene 019), yet on 1 Apr YTSDB he comes "around HmH to do an emergency load of laundry" like an HmH resident (p. 250) — unresolved tension between the two accounts of where Hal lived in YTSDB.
  • Foil and bottle echoes with Joelle's OD one cluster back (scene 062): JOI packs the door-hole with wadded foil / Joelle cooks her freebase on foil (p. 238); the half-full gift-bowed Wild Turkey / her half-empty glass — the two suicide apparatuses built from the same kitchen materials.
  • Carlisle leaves the truth-value of the "smelled delicious" scream open ("noticed something right away," p. 250, may already have been the smell — before the kitchen); our reading follows Hal's own "which was the truth," but carry the ambiguity.

Forward

  • The wheelchair watchers are the A.F.R., surveilling Orin as the likeliest route to the Master copy; this thread runs to the Subject-"Swiss hand-model" honeytrap and Orin's torture under the tumbler (pp. 971-972, "Do it to her").
  • "Helen" Steeply's profile pretext: scene 061's putative CV is the paperwork; the Moment angle continues through Steeply's E.T.A. visit and the deLint conversations (pp. 654 ff., 1047 ff.).
  • The face-in-the-floor nightmare (p. 253) was already rendered at scene 019 (pp. 61-63) and recurs as Hal's signature dread; the "psychic credit-card bill" Schacht imagines for Hal (scene 065, p. 270) names the same deferred reckoning.
  • Joelle's "he hadn't had a drop in weeks" condition (p. 250) corroborates n.80's account of the final cartridge's making; the bow on the Wild Turkey reads as a suicide's sardonic gift — cf. the wraith's later account of why he made the Entertainment for Hal (pp. 838-839, scene 162).
  • This is the FIRST Orin-Hal call; the SECOND — Sat 7 Nov YDAU, I-Day Eve, answered in person after the Pemberton eye-socket incident — is endnote 110, with its own scene file (scene n110). Keep the two distinct: this one carries the suicide forensics and grief-therapy; n.110 carries the Separatism/Moms material and the 'Jethro Bodine' form-reply machinery that Orin's p. 244 "pseudo-form-replies" jab points at.
  • Orin's wheelchaired watchers rhyme with Geoffrey Day's comic "box-surveillance" paranoia in n.90 (see scene 066 and scene n090) — the same A.F.R. iconography read as nuisance in one register and D.T.s in the other.
  • Carlisle's forensic reading (recorded, his adjudication): the chalk lines around the shoes, the gesture at the walls, "what was left of the microwave," and the diggable head of p. 17 (scene 003) together suggest the blast coursed down through the body (his Hamlet I.v ear-poison analogy) rather than the "popped spud" Orin infers — squares the gallows joke with the scene-003/late-book head-digging visions. Cite the text as written; useful when reconciling p. 17 (scene 003).

Notable passages (13)

  • p. 244: "The sated ghost cannot see secret things." — the Aht dictum; epigraph-grade for the whole wraith system, planted as trivia.
  • p. 247: Hal's catalog of what Orin won't be forthright about ("Himself and annulation… Himself killing himself, you and Joelle…") — the family's whole secret architecture in one breath; prime family-hamlet extraction.
  • p. 248: "Talking about it's broken the spell. Now I'm self-conscious and afraid." — The Zone destroyed by reflection; key the-body-tennis passage.
  • p. 248: "The microwave, O. The rotisserie microwave over next to the fridge…" — Hal's hyper-precise kitchen geography as deflected trauma; the deadpan that carries the scene's horror.
  • p. 249: "Found by one Harold James Incandenza, thirteen going on really old." — the disclosure in third-person legalese; self-distancing in one clause.
  • pp. 251-252: the potato/TNT exchange — gallows physics; "Hence the need to reconstruct the scene."
  • p. 253: the pathologist who drew the chalk lines around Himself's shoes, gestured at the walls, and threw up — the unshowable scene rendered entirely by reaction shot.
  • p. 253: "It was like one of those final exams in nightmares where you prepare immaculately and then you get there and all the exam questions are in Hindi." — performance-Hal meets an authority who won't define the goods; also the "352 pages of sheer goo" library-binge run-up.
  • p. 255: "I called a cab, still in my towel… 'The nearest library with a cutting-edge professional grief- and trauma-therapy section, and step on it.'" — the Lyle insight in action; comic hinge of the whole arc.
  • pp. 255-256: the anger presentation — validate, process-as-transitive-verb, toxic guilt, the Abrupt Pause in High-Affect Speech — the breakdown assembled from the therapist's own literature.
  • p. 256: "'That something smelled delicious!' I screamed." — the novel's most appalling true sentence; grief, appetite, and guilt fused.
  • p. 257: the tiny hands reveal — authority's body deflated; Hal's "hysterical mirth" (stall-to-stall head-beating) as the only release the therapy actually produced.
  • pp. 257-258: the talons/coccyx/"bladdery sac" coda and "And the word is asphyxiated" — Hal's swerve into the prehuman, then the call ended on a copyedit; communication-solipsism in miniature.

What links here Timeline events here (37) · Connected from (19) · Passages quoted here (75) · Motifs (5)

Timeline events here

Connected from

Passages quoted here

Motifs