IJ study archive

Scene n321: hal pemulis dmz quitting

Pages
1063–1066
When
Thurs 12 Nov YDAU (2009), 1930h, per the note's own dateline
Where
E.T.A., Rm. 204 Subdorm B (Pemulis's room; 'Let me just close this door, here')in: E.T.A. (Enfield Tennis Academy) › E.T.A. subdormitories
POV
pure dialogue, zero narration — an endnote exhibit ('Q.v. for a confirming example…')

Connects to (editorial cuts & payoffs, 14)

Summary

Evening of 12 Nov YDAU, behind Pemulis's closed door: what begins as Boards-prep calculus tutoring (derivatives as "trig with some imagination") becomes the novel's most direct Hal-Pemulis exchange about need. Hal recounts a DMZ-dream in which he was Pemulis's Leavenworth test convict — screaming for help while everyone around him hears Ethel Merman covers — and then floats, in "what if" armor, the real news: he's been off everything for two-and-a-half days and is contemplating quitting "everything. Forever." Pemulis, simultaneously lobbying for the post-Fundraiser DMZ session and genuinely alarmed for his friend, delivers his anti-AA counter-doctrine: an addict who needs it and quits cold doesn't get better, he dies inside — the walking dead with keys in their backs — so the only real move is the strategic switch ("the right switch for a man's wiring"). It is Hal who drags Himself into it — "A Clipperton, you mean? You're saying Himself killed himself because he got sober?… So don't try to kertwang me with him, Mike" — and Pemulis disclaims the analogy ("what I know about your Da could be inscribed with a blunt crayon along the rim of a shot glass"), testifying instead from Allston: "I'm talking guys I know. Wolf Spiders. Allston guys, that quit. Some did a Clipperton, yes." The note ends with Pemulis refusing Hal the comfort of the label: "'The part that's dependent or incomplete, you mean. The addict.' / 'That's just a word.'" Read against Year of Glad, the dream and the white-knuckle prophecy are the book's clearest forecast of Hal's ending.

What to notice

The plot key to Hal's ending is filed as a footnote: pure dialogue behind a closed door, zero narration, hidden below the line — the book's most consequential conversation about need, deliberately easy to skip. The Merman dream is the novel's most economical self-forecast: Hal as the test convict "screaming for help" while everyone hears show tunes — exactly the condition of the opening interview, dreamed a year in advance and reported to the one person partly responsible. Notice the scene's central refusal: Hal can approach the truth only in "what if" armor, and the sentence breaks off before the noun — "the difference between really loving something and being—" — with Pemulis's "Say the word, Inc." answered by ellipsis; the closing exchange ("The addict." / "That's just a word.") is the diagnosis offered and declined in four words. Pemulis's counter-doctrine — quit cold and "You die inside", the walking dead with keys in their backs — is the anti-AA gospel whose rebuttal is the entire Ennet House half of the novel, which this conversation never hears; and his own image gives the game away: he calls white-knuckling hoisting "the white flag", unknowingly naming the AA group where the book's other recovering addict is saved. One more knife: the tutor warning Hal off quitting is the supplier whose Tenuates get him expelled five days later.

Beats — page-by-page

  • p. 1063: Rise Over Run — Pemulis the gifted tutor: derivatives demystified ("You imagine the points moving inexorably toward each other"), Eschaton invoked as the harder math, O.N.A.N. currency inflation as a word-problem example; the plug-in formula (rendered in the electronic text as a garbled "nx + xn-1" — print has the proper n·x^(n-1)).
  • p. 1063: Hal trades momentum for confession: "It was a DMZ-dream… your experimental soldier, the massive dose… the Leavenworth convict. The one you said had left the planet. The one belting out Ethel Merman. In the dream I was the soldier." Pemulis closes the door.
  • p. 1064: The dream's content — "I wasn't really singing 'There's No Business Like Show Business.' I was really screaming for help… and everybody's acting as if I'm singing Ethel Merman covers!" — wardens and doctors snapping their fingers and tapping their feet; "a quality of loneliness to it… Unlike anything." Pemulis files it as "a Rusk-level dream, Inc. A standard nobody-understands-me dream."
  • p. 1064: DMZ logistics: it doesn't show on a G.C./M.S. (Struck's Digestive-Flora footnote; the fitviavi-mold base reads as imbalanced yeast); Struck has nearly confirmed its 1960s origin — transcendent experiences for chronic alcoholics, Verdun Protestant Hospital, Montreal.
  • p. 1064: The Québec convergence, noticed by Hal himself: Orin "calling with some protracted obsession about anti-O.N.A.N. Québecers," Tavis announcing Québec as this year's fundraiser opponents, "Your Mum's from Québec," Poutrincourt's insurgency class "basically a Québecathon" — Pemulis jokes "I'd suspect some kind of conspiracy or trap… everything's pointing toward getting you in a cell belting out Mermanalia."
  • p. 1064: Pemulis's great Bob Hope aria — Hal's hinges "starting to squeak" from plateaux-hopping; the DMZ pitched as "just the reconfiguration you need"; the portrait of the chronic pot casualty ("fat, soft, moist and pale… spending their lives in front of the TP, eating Nutter Butters"); the Shit Fairy moves in with luggage; "Leave the Visine at home."
  • pp. 1064-1065: Hal's "what if": more than a month off — "maybe make a decision. Forever… it was getting less fun but I was still doing it more and more, and the only way to moderate would be to like wave a hankie at it altogether" — everything: Bob Hope, Blue Flames, the odd 'drine, and the DMZ too ("I'd drop Madame Psychosis with you guys" — the drug's street name). "Abandon All Hope" gets the lettered sub-footnote a (q.v. n.334).
  • p. 1065: The word neither will say: needing vs. loving — "think how horrible that'd be, if somebody needed it. Not just liked it a great great great deal… It seems like the difference between really loving something and being—" / "Say the word, Inc." / ellipsis.
  • p. 1065: Pemulis's machine argument: "What if you are? … if you need it what do you imagine happens if you just hoist the white flag and try to go on without it, without anything? … You lose your mind, Inc. You die inside." Hal catches the contradiction with the just-delivered tits-and-cobwebs picture; Pemulis clarifies the doctrine: you can only quit the Bob "if you move onward and up to something else" — the strategic switch (heroin to Coors, booze to the Bob; "the right switch for a man's wiring").
  • p. 1065: Hal names the lobbying ("you're in a very subtle way lobbying for a DMZ-drop… With your left eye wobbling all over the place. You haven't even quit the Tenuate") and the Himself collision: "A Clipperton, you mean? You're saying Himself killed himself because he got sober? Because he didn't get sober. There was a thing of Wild Turkey right there on the counter by the oven… So don't try to kertwang me with him, Mike."
  • pp. 1065-1066: Pemulis disclaims ("what I know about your Da could be inscribed with a blunt crayon along the rim of a shot glass") and testifies instead from Allston: Wolf Spiders who quit everything — some did a Clipperton, some the Mental Marriott, some the God-Squad ("not going to work for you because you're too sharp"), and most just went dead: "Like machines; you could almost see the keys in their backs. You looked into their maps and something was gone. The walking dead."
  • p. 1066: The pivot to now: "it's been what… two-and-a-half days without? three days? How you feeling in there already, brother?" / "I'm all right." Pemulis's last offer of pure friendship (hold our purses, do what you want) plus the advice to "look a little further past that second of deciding"; the homework — "what part of you's come to need it, do you think" — and the close: "The part that's dependent or incomplete, you mean. The addict." / "That's just a word."

Themes in this scene

  • Addiction and Recovery: the anti-AA gospel according to Pemulis — substitution over abstinence, "Cold Turkey… the Bird. White-knuckling" as death — set against Hal's first honest sight of the like/need line; the whole Ennet House half of the novel is the rebuttal this conversation never hears.
  • Communication and Solipsism: the Merman dream is the book's perfect image of unreachable interiority — screaming for help received as entertainment — and it is precisely Hal's condition in scene 001; even here, Hal can only approach the truth as "what if" and can't say the word "addict."
  • Depression and Anhedonia: Pemulis's walking dead — "they got up and went to work and came home and ate and went to sleep… But dead… Something was all over, inside" — is anhedonia described from the street side, anticipating Hal's own gray November interior.
  • Fathers and Sons: Himself surfaces as the unavoidable test case, raised by Hal himself; his preemptive fury at any "kertwang" with his Da — and his factual counter (the Wild Turkey by the oven) — guards a wound the novel elsewhere reopens: the question of whether JOI's late sobriety is what killed him inside.
  • Dreams: the DMZ-dream reported to the one person partly responsible — Hal as Pemulis's Leavenworth test convict, "screaming for help" while wardens and doctors hear Ethel Merman covers and tap their feet, with "a quality of loneliness to it... Unlike anything" (p. 1064); the book's clearest dream-foreshadow of scene 001, filed by Pemulis as "a standard nobody-understands-me dream."

Connections — backward & forward

Backward

  • Pemulis's substitution doctrine vs. the AA material: n.90 and the White Flag scenes stage the opposite claim — that the cage admits no strategic switch; Gately's grief for the Substance (scene 066, pp. 272-273) is what "needing" looks like honestly mourned. Note Pemulis's own image: quitting cold = "hoist the white flag" — the name of Gately's AA group.
  • Sub-footnote a ("Abandon All Hope") cross-references n.334.
  • The Leavenworth/Ethel Merman convict comes from the DMZ exposition at pp. ~211-219 (with the fitviavi pharmacology); the physical DMZ was bartered from Antitoi Entertainment pp. 481-482, scene 097. "Madame Psychosis" as the drug's street name triangulates with Joelle's radio persona and JOI's lethal film — three Madame Psychoses, one lineage.

Forward

  • Referencing superscript: in Hal's I-feel-a-hole exchange with Mario (scene 157, pp. 782-785), as "a confirming example" of the Pemulis dynamic described there — the [n.321] marker sits in raw 157.
  • The dream is the strongest single foreshadow of the YG frame (scenes 001/003, pp. 3-17): Hal producing what he believes is speech while the deans hear subanimalistic noises — and it is core evidence for the DMZ-dosing theory of Hal's final condition. The Pemulis/Hal endgame continues in n.324.
  • Hal's quitting clock: the O.N.A.N.T.A. urologist's 30-day window (scene 102, pp. 508-527) precipitated abstinence beginning ~9-10 Nov; "two-and-a-half days" here calibrates it. The withdrawal Pemulis prophesies is tracked through Hal's late sections.
  • "You haven't even quit the Tenuate" + the wobbling left eye: the same pilfered Tenuates accidentally dose John Wayne and get Pemulis expelled in n.332 — five days after this scene.
  • The Himself argument points at the Joelle/Notkin accounts of JOI's last months (pp. 755-795), where JOI's new sobriety just before the microwave undercuts Hal's factual counter and fits the very analogy he rejects; "you looked into their maps and something was gone" also echoes Clipperton (scenes 086/089) — "eliminating one's own map" in the archive's maps-territory sense, though here "map" is Allston for face.
  • The Québec convergence Hal jokes about is a real noose: Orin's calls (scene 064; n.110), Poutrincourt (scene 070 and her Steeply contact later on), the Québec junior squad fundraiser → the A.F.R.'s actual operational interest in the Incandenzas late in the book.

Notable passages (6)

  • p. 1063: "You use your goddamn imagination, Inc, plus a couple prescribed limits." — Pemulis's calculus pedagogy; the tutor at his genuine best, and limits as the scene's hidden pun.
  • p. 1064: "I was screaming like 'Help! … It's me, screaming for help!'" — the Merman dream; the book's most economical image of Hal's ending and of solipsism generally.
  • p. 1064: the Bob Hope aria ("The shit-fairy moves in with luggage for an extended stay, Inc") — Pemulis's comic-prophetic register at full power.
  • p. 1065: "It seems like the difference between really loving something and being—" / "Say the word, Inc." — the unsayable word; quintessential Hal.
  • pp. 1065-1066: "You lose your mind, Inc. You die inside… Like machines; you could almost see the keys in their backs… The walking dead." — the white-knuckle prophecy; key anhedonia text from the non-recovery side.
  • p. 1066: "'The addict.' / 'That's just a word.'" — the closing exchange; Pemulis refusing the noun Hal is trying on.

What links here Manuscript differences (2) · Timeline events here (11) · Connected from (28) · Endnote digest of (2) · Passages quoted here (33)

Manuscript differences

Timeline events here

Connected from

Endnote digest of

Passages quoted here