IJ study archive

Scene 076: aa raquel mask speaker

Scene
76
Pages
367–375
When
8 November YDAU (2009), Interdependence Day — White Flag meeting continued, same evening as scene 074
Where
Provident Nursing Home cafeteria, Hanneman Street, Enfield (White Flag AA speaker meeting, second half)in: Provident Nursing Home (White Flag AA)
POV
3rd person, Gately-centric free indirect / essayistic Boston-AA narrator (continuous with scene 074)

Connects to (editorial cuts & payoffs, 10)

Summary

The White Flag meeting's second half becomes a taxonomy of what does and doesn't "go over" at a Boston AA podium. A polished, performing newcomer dies of the crowd's empathetic embarrassment, while a terrified ex-Complaint-Department man's artless story of hiding under his desk pounding a hammer brings the house down — because "it wasn't meant to be one bit funny: it was just the truth." The narration codifies the rules: it has to be truth, unslanted and maximally unironic ("An ironist in a Boston AA meeting is a witch in church"), lip-service is fine ("Fake It Till You Make It") but causal attribution is death — illustrated at hideous length by the hard-faced stripper whose etiology (the catatonic foster sister "It," the smiling diddling father, the Raquel Welch mask, the mirror-lit post-coital face matching the household's ecstatic-saint photo) curdles the room's empathy precisely because it's pitched as exterior Cause. The section closes on Boston AA's "real Prime Directive" — no Whys — engraved by a long-gone ironist in doggerel on a commode seat. Throughout, Gately broods on the previous raffle-break's "odd old dark moment of aphasiac terror" with the veiled girl and on where he could possibly know that smooth, echoless, slightly Southern voice from.

What to notice

The scene sets a trap, and the trap is the narrator. Pages after declaring the podium an irony-free zone, the narration retells the stripper's testimony as an ironist would — mock-heroic inflation ("nay and the whole community of Saugus MA"), talk-show snark, even a parenthetical "But For the Grace of God, in a way" that redeploys, deadpan, the exact subjunctive Joelle demolished at the raffle break — and an endnote admits the fanciest diction is the narrator's, not the girl's. The reader is thereby maneuvered into the position of the male eyes in the audience: consuming as lurid comedy precisely what the room is being taught not to. Form does doctrine too: the whole etiology arrives as one avalanche sentence, semicolons chaining "and how" and "and then but" across three pages, so the audience's dread that this will get "head-clutchingly prolix" is enacted on you in real time — you clutch your head at the syntax before the content. The story's true nadir hides in a subordinate clause: the speaker identifies her own bed only as "the one without the collapsible crib-like hospital railings along the sides" — a childhood defined by the protective hardware it lacked, trailed off in ellipsis. And Its lit-up face is the book's terminal image — bliss past the human, the attaché's slack gaze, the stone saint's ecstasy — planted in the one register the meeting's first half never used: testimony that fails, and fails precisely by explaining.

Beats — page-by-page

  • pp. 367-368: the unfunny rehearsed newcomer; Boston AA's ego-radar; deprecating the Program rather than the Self as "the subtle but cardinal Message-offense"; the host crowd's worst punishment — getting embarrassed for you; applause "with the relieved feel of a fist unclenching."
  • pp. 368-369: the Filene's Complaint Dept. man — hammer kept under the desk, "whacketa whacketa," diving under at every knock for nearly the last year of his drinking — and the Crocodiles roaring with Identification because it was just the truth.
  • p. 369: the poetics of the podium: truth "unslanted, unfortified… maximally unironic"; "An ironist in a Boston AA meeting is a witch in church. Irony-free zone"; pseudo-sincerity feared as much as irony; Gately meanwhile brooding on the veiled "pseudo-intellectual-type girl" and her hauntingly familiar voice.
  • pp. 369-370: "Fake It Till You Make It"; the Program's "definite cultish, brainwashy elements" and Gately's candor about handing his brain to Pat M. and Gene M. for the scrub ("more like deprogramming than actual washing," given the Spider's psychic job); Gately's verbal-honesty discipline — saying "Lucky" instead of "Grateful" because only the former is always true; Ferocious Francis's shoulder-punch: right where he's supposed to be.
  • p. 370: causal attribution = death, podium-wise; the skinny hard-faced girl — "a member of a splinter 12-Step Fellowship, an Adult-Child-type thing called Wounded, Hurting, Inadequately Nurtured but Ever-Recovering Survivors" (p. 372; Carlisle brackets the acronym [WHINERS]) — posits stripping-at-sixteen as Cause; male eyes do the "crawly north-to-south thing"; "Gately can see every ashtray on the table shake from the force of Joelle V.'s shudder" at the Naked I reference.
  • pp. 370-372: the etiology unspools — adopted into a foster home with a paralyzed catatonic biological daughter the mother insists be treated as normal ("It," dragged to slumber parties, school, double dates); the quiet smiling Aetna-claims-processor father's nightly "advantage"; the Raquel Welch full-head mask, "RAQUEL!" in extremity; the speaker's silent tidyings-up to preserve the mother's Denial — and the cold calculus that if the diddling stopped, she'd be "promoted to the role of Raquel."
  • pp. 372-374: the seminally scarring night — the mask's horsehair tangled in Its moussed coiffure, the vanity-mirror lights, Its lit-up post-diddle face contracted into "a carnal bliss beyond smiles or sighs" (n.142: the diction is the narrator's, not hers — though she really did say chordate phylum); the identical expression on the household's devotional photo of a hiked-robed stone saint with arrow-pointing cherub; flight to Route 1, stripping, the needle, "rasa the tabula."
  • p. 374: the room's heads clutched "only partly in empathy" — self-pity less offensive than the appeal to exterior Cause; the Why of the Disease as a labyrinth "inhabited… by the twin minotaurs of Why Me? and Why Not?"; In Here vs. Out There; the Disease as the thing "eating your heart raw and (if you're lucky) eliminating your map for good."
  • pp. 374-375: Boston AA's root axiom as "almost classically authoritarian, maybe even proto-Fascist"; the YTMP ironist's rosewood-handled-boot-knife commode-seat engraving: "Do not ask WHY / If you dont want to DIE / Do like your TOLD / If you want to get OLD" (n.143: Sic).

Themes in this scene

  • Addiction and Recovery: the deep grammar of AA testimony — Identification, Message, Cause-vs.-responsibility — anatomized through three contrasting speakers.
  • Irony and Sincerity: this scene's thesis statement — irony as literal anathema ("witch in church"), the unfunny-truth/funny-performance inversion, and the dead ironist's mocking doggerel that nonetheless states the Program's truth.
  • Communication and Solipsism: an audience that punishes by empathizing; Gately's effort "to really hear" while his mind keeps sliding to the unplaceable voice; truth as the only transmissible signal.
  • Disability and Deformity: "It" — the paralyzed, faceless-expressioned catatonic — the book's most appalling entry in its register of damaged bodies treated as objects; Joelle's veiled shudder yokes her to the material twice over.
  • Maps and Territory: the Disease "eliminating your map for good" (p. 374) — the suicide idiom recurring at the axiom's center.

Connections — backward & forward

Backward

  • Continuous with scene 074 (same meeting): Gately's brooding on the "aphasiac terror" moment (p. 369) is the p. 366 subjunctive exchange; the voice mystery again points at Joelle's Madame Psychosis radio identity (pp. 181-193) and stays unresolved.
  • The devotional photo is (unnamed) Bernini's Ecstasy of St. Teresa — the same ecstatic-annihilation iconography the book attaches to the Entertainment's lethal bliss (cf. the attaché scenes 007/011/014/025/028: pleasure that erases the face).

Forward

  • The stripper's "It" anticipates Joelle's own contested deformity/beauty question (Notkin's account, pp. 788-795) and the U.H.I.D. veil logic — a face that cannot be looked at; her shudder and billowing veil here and in scene 079 mark her private Identifications.
  • The Raquel Welch mask — a dead sex-goddess's empty face strapped onto a faceless body — rhymes with the Entertainment's veiled/masked mother-death figure (Joelle as Madame Psychosis in Infinite Jest (V?), described pp. 788ff and n.24) and with every smily-face mask in scene 074.
  • "Why Me?/Why Not?" minotaurs and the no-Cause axiom set up Gately's later crisis of How-without-Why (the Big Question with Ferocious Francis, pp. 442ff) and Marathe's barroom meditation on choice with Kate Gompert (scene 156, pp. 774ff).
  • The commode-seat graffiti's author — an ironist who "decamped back Out There" — is irony's own cautionary tale, the book's verdict in miniature (cf. the anti-irony essayistic burst at pp. 369-374 with Hal's "hip cynical transcendence" worry, p. 694, scene 135).

Notable passages (5)

  • p. 368: "The worst punishment Gately's seen inflicted on a Commitment speaker is when the host crowd gets embarrassed for him." — empathy as discipline.
  • p. 369: "it was just the truth… It can't be a calculated crowd-pleaser, and it has to be the truth unslanted, unfortified. And maximally unironic. An ironist in a Boston AA meeting is a witch in church. Irony-free zone." — the book's irony-sincerity credo at its most explicit.
  • p. 373: "some hideously mobile and expressive layer… had blindly contracted… into the sort of pinched gasping look of neurologic concentration that marks a carnal bliss beyond smiles or sighs." — Its face; the bliss-beyond-the-human that is also the Entertainment's signature.
  • p. 374: "The Why of the Disease is a labyrinth… inhabited… by the twin minotaurs of Why Me? and Why Not?" — Cause vs. responsibility, the scene's doctrinal core.
  • pp. 374-375: "Do not ask WHY / If you dont want to DIE…" — the proto-Fascist Prime Directive in latrine doggerel; irony and obedience in one artifact.

What links here Timeline events here (4) · Connected from (5) · Passages quoted here (51) · Motifs (2)

Timeline events here

Connected from

Passages quoted here

Motifs