IJ study archive

Scene 100: na hug roy tony

Scene
100
Pages
503–507
When
Monday 9 Nov YDAU (2009) — 'the night after' the 8 Nov joint Interdependence Day picnic (p. 503)
Where
NA Beginners' Discussion Meeting (marijuana-focus), anechoic vestry of an upscale church, 'west Belmont or east Waltham' MAin: Other AA/NA meetings
POV
Ken Erdedy (3rd person, free-indirect — the wary spectator's view of NA)

Connects to (editorial cuts & payoffs, 13)

Summary

Johnette Foltz takes Ennet House's two marijuana casualties, Ken Erdedy and Kate Gompert, to metro Boston's only NA meeting devoted to grass, so they can see "how completely nonunique and unalone" they are. The meeting delivers a definitive clinical catalog of marijuana addiction and withdrawal, over which clinical depression hangs unnamed, "fog-like," while Gompert mimes shooting herself in the temple. At the close comes the ritual Erdedy can't tolerate: rampant indiscriminate hugging. His genteel refusal of a hug from a huge ex-street figure named Roy Tony escalates — through Erdedy's ironizing verbiage and Roy's furious literalism — until Roy, holding Erdedy off the floor one-handed, explains that nobody likes the hugs: "We fucking do what they tell us... We done motherfucking surrendered our wills in here," and offers a choice between hugging and decapitation. The scene ends with Erdedy embracing him so hard "it looked like Erdedy was trying to climb him."

What to notice

The scene is a duel of registers before it is anything else: Erdedy's subordinate-clause armor — the hyphenation filibuster over Roy's name, the offer of "intricate multiple-handed ethnic handshakes" — against a man whose menace arrives already fused to program language. Listen to the ultimatum: "hug my ass or do I gone fucking rip your head off and shit down your neck?" lives inside a sentence about consenting to "risk vulnerability and discomfort" — recovery-speak and street threat not opposed but grammatically welded, which is why an onlooker claps and shouts "Talk about it!": to the clean-and-sober set the assault is legible as sharing, and she is not wrong. Notice Erdedy's engine still running from his first scene: the joggling foot that knocks over his coffee "not once but twice", and, at the first flash of danger — Roy still frozen mid-pre-hug, arms out, the smile draining — a mind "trying to calculate just what remote sub-Asian locale would be the maximum possible number of km. away": the couch's obsessive-analysis paralysis firing before a hand has even touched him. The hugging itself is filmed as crowd mechanics — "It was like somebody'd thrown a switch", "Jowls ground into other jowls" — with Erdedy the connoisseur cataloguing the missing back-thumps of male protocol he refuses to perform. Johnette's rescue patter cycles the entire address-book — "Dude, Man, Esse, Bro, Posse, Crew, Homes, Jim, Brother" — a comic hunt for the one register that will land, the scene's whole problem in miniature. And the final sentence leaps out of its own moment into future gossip, Erdedy's conversion certified secondhand, already community property.

Beats — page-by-page

  • p. 503: setup — night after the chilly joint I-Day picnic, Johnette Foltz escorts Erdedy and Gompert to the Beginners' marijuana meeting; the room of ~two dozen in a huge circle, ashtrays on knees, kicked-over coffee.
  • pp. 503-504: the shared testimony: "marijuana destroys slowly but thoroughly"; the single-sentence symptom catalog — isolation, anxious lassitude, hyperself-consciousness, emotional catalepsy, the obsessive couch-analysis paralysis, then detox's insomnia, ceased menses, sweats, tremors, drool-cups — and the shame that neither M.D.s nor hard-drug NAs respect "nature's humblest buzz" as a real addiction.
  • p. 504: nobody names melancholy / anhedonia / clinical depression, "this worst of symptoms, this logarithm of all suffering," which hangs gassy and dreaded over the room; Gompert's finger-revolver suicide pantomime until Johnette whispers to knock it off.
  • p. 504: Erdedy's spectator mode — says nothing, observes closely, cracks knuckles; the "motley disrespectability" demographics, psych-ward I.D. bracelets not yet cut off.
  • p. 504: the close: NA's "Just For Today," the ragged Our Father ("And lead us not into Penn Station," Gompert swears she heard), Keep Coming Back It Works.
  • pp. 504-505: "kind of horrifically," the switch flips: rampant, indiscriminate, conversationless hugging — male-to-male embraces without even the requisite back-thumps; Johnette "racking up serious numbers"; even Gompert participates; Erdedy retreats to the Conference-Approved-Literature table and feigns interest in the coffee urn.
  • p. 505: Roy Tony — tall, fatigue jacket, gold incisor — spreads his arms for a hug; Erdedy's benign No Thanks and proffered card-introduction ("Ken E., Ennet House, Enfield. How do you do"); Roy's hand-behind-neck blatant dis.
  • pp. 505-506: Erdedy's class-bound filibuster ("unless it's a compound first name, hyphenated, 'Roy-Tony'...") meets escalating street logic: "So man what you say you saying I'm a hugger?"
  • p. 506: Roy hoists Erdedy by the anorak lapels, one-handed, off the floor: "We fucking do what they tell us. They tell us Hugs Not Drugs in here. We done motherfucking surrendered our wills in here"; his confession — four hugs his first night, then ran to the can and puked; the James-River-Traders/Calvin-Klein anatomization of Erdedy.
  • pp. 506-507: an onlooker claps and shouts "Talk about it!"; Roy: you "disrespect me in front of my whole clean and sober set just when I gone risk sharing my vulnerability and discomfort with you?"; Johnette paws at his jacket, mentally drafting the Staff Log entry.
  • p. 507: the ultimatum — "you gone risk vulnerability and discomfort and hug my ass or do I gone fucking rip your head off and shit down your neck?" — and Erdedy's conversion: hugging with such vigor Gompert later tells Joelle van Dyne "it looked like Erdedy was trying to climb him." (Dialect note: Roy's speech is rendered in the text's Boston street register; Erdedy's in fussy professional-class qualifications — the collision of registers is the scene's engine.)

Themes in this scene

  • Addiction and Recovery: NA's machinery shown whole — testimony, slogans, ritual closure, coerced fellowship; Roy's "we do what they tell us" is the program's epistemology (compliance precedes belief) stated by its least likely exponent.
  • Depression and Anhedonia: anhedonia as the one symptom too dreaded to name, hanging fog-like over the circle; Gompert's silent revolver pantomime keeps her suicide thread (pp. 68-78) alive in the margin.
  • Irony and Sincerity: Erdedy's ironical, qualifying, distance-making politeness is physically seized and forced into a single-entendre embrace; the comedy is postmodern self-protection losing — by terror — to sincerity.
  • Communication and Solipsism: Erdedy spectates rather than shares, calculates the maximally distant sub-Asian locale mid-encounter, and is saved only by contact he cannot verbally negotiate his way out of.

Connections — backward & forward

Backward

  • Johnette Foltz shepherding Erdedy and Gompert to the meeting links to the White Flag world of scenes 074-080 (pp. 343-379); her Staff Log dread is the staffer's-eye view of the same institution.
  • The hug-phobia and its forced breach rhyme with the book's recurring lesson that the cliché works whether you believe it or not (Gately on the gratitude/prayer stuff, pp. 369, scene 076ff).

Forward

  • Erdedy's first appearance is scene 004 (pp. 17-27), splayed between phone and buzzer waiting for 200 grams — the obsessive-analysis paralysis catalogued abstractly here (pp. 503-504) is precisely his own case history; his arc continues at Ennet House (he recurs in House scenes through the Lenz-era chapters).
  • Kate Gompert: the psych-ward interview (pp. 68-78, scene 024) gave the full clinical interior of what the room won't name; her thread runs on to the It monologue territory (pp. 692-698, scene 135) and her YDAU encounter with Rémy Marathe (pp. 774, scene 156ff).
  • Roy Tony is the Brighton Projects figure of Clenette Henderson's monologue (scene 008, pp. 37-38 — Wardine's abuser); not Poor Tony Krause. His presence here, under a year clean and raging at the program he obeys, is the novel quietly running its most menacing street figure through recovery; and Clenette herself surfaces two scenes later working at E.T.A. (p. 527, scene 102) — the Brighton thread brackets these scenes.
  • "Hugs Not Drugs" / surrendered wills sets up these scenes' sharpest juxtaposition: the very next scene (101) gives Hank Hoyne, "an American adult of exemplary self-control," destroyed by the Entertainment — surrendered will as salvation vs. autonomous will as no defense at all.

Notable passages (5)

  • pp. 503-504: the marijuana-withdrawal catalog sentence ("the social isolation, anxious lassitude... the particularly nasty excess production of saliva") — the book's definitive clinical portrait of cannabis dependence.
  • p. 504: "this worst of symptoms, this logarithm of all suffering, seemed, though unmentioned, to hang fog-like just over the room's heads" — anhedonia theme anchor.
  • p. 504: "And lead us not into Penn Station" — the recovery-room mondegreen; comic sincerity-noise.
  • p. 506: "We fucking do what they tell us. They tell us Hugs Not Drugs in here. We done motherfucking surrendered our wills in here" — surrender doctrine from the program's angriest adherent.
  • p. 507: "it looked like Erdedy was trying to climb him" — the closing image: terror-assisted embrace as the chapter's punchline and moral.

What links here Timeline events here (8) · Connected from (8) · Passages quoted here (27) · Motifs (1)

Timeline events here

Connected from

Passages quoted here

Motifs