Scene 101: entertainment casualties
Characters present
Characters referenced
Open questions this scene bears on
Connects to
- Scene 007: attache receives cartridge
- Scene 011: attache still watching
- Scene 014: attache wets recliner
- Scene 025: attache wife watches
- Scene 028: attache room fills
- Scene 098: master copies temptation
- Scene 100: na hug roy tony
- Scene 103: odalisque myths
- Scene 107: tine samizdat dossier
- Scene 135: anhedonia and it
- Scene 147: afr finds entertainment
- Scene 162: gately wraith figurants
Summary
A short installment of the Marathe/Steeply mountainside serial: Steeply admits that Unspecified Services has lost its own people to the Entertainment during testing — first an intern who borrowed Flatto's I/O clearance card to see what the fuss was, then, far worse, Hank Hoyne, the twenty-year head of Data Analysis, who went in to pull the intern out. Hoyne is now in four-point restraints, tube-fed, with "no desire or even basic survival-type will for anything other than more viewing." Steeply's point cuts against the night's running argument: Hoyne was no undisciplined pleasure-seeking child but "an American adult of exemplary self-control and discretion," who once renounced all sugar at his diabetes diagnosis without a backward glance. In the continuation, Steeply confesses he is as terrified as intrigued, quotes the night-shift's memo-phrase for victims' eyes — "Empty of intent" — and Marathe answers that terror is itself part of the American temptation; the A.F.R., by contrast, thinks only of the ends the weapon may serve and does "not fool crazily about."
What to notice
The elegy for Hank Hoyne has to pass through the disguise — Steeply kneading a bare shoulder while Marathe needles him about "your sleeveless skirt and different breasts" — and the friend himself is mourned in consumer particulars: "The iron will, the analytic savvy. His love of a fine cigar." Overhead the sky restages the two men as a double portrait: Perseus's legs "amputated by the earth's horizon" above the legless Marathe, one of Castor's legs "inbent in a feminine manner" above the operative in a dress. The argument is quietly lexicographic — "Perhaps we are meaning different things by this" — temptation meaning appetite to Steeply and efficacy to Marathe, a gap no casualty report closes. And between the Glad memoir's gibbering rats and Pemulis's rodential chair a page ahead, Marathe's own wheelchair gives "small squeaks" as he shifts — the book's dread-noise threading even the desert dark.
Beats
- p. 507: Steeply: "We've lost a couple already" — the Data Analysis intern who used Tom Flatto's I/O-lab clearance card and viewed one of the Read-Only copies.
- p. 507: Marathe coolly recites Hoyne's dossier — "Hoyne, Henri or pronounce 'Henry,' middle initial of F., with the wife, with his adult diabetes he controls" — a flash of how deeply the A.F.R. has penetrated B.S.S. personnel files.
- p. 507: Hoyne's condition: four-point restraints, nourishment through a tube, will for nothing but more viewing; Steeply's failed visit ("with your sleeveless skirt and different breasts," Marathe needles) — Hoyne begging for "a trailer, a snatch of soundtrack, anything," eyes "wobbling around like some drug-addicted newborn."
- p. 507: the argument-turning testimony: Hoyne put down all sugar and treats at diagnosis "and walked away. Not even a whimper or backward glance... An American adult of exemplary self-control and discretion" — iron will is no defense.
- p. 507: Marathe: "The samizdat is not to be played crazily about with, so. We too have lost persons. It is serious."
- p. 508: the legs of Perseus "amputated by the earth's horizon," Castor and Pollux over legless Marathe's shoulder; Steeply asks whether Marathe ever fantasizes about viewing; Marathe: "we think of what ends the Entertainment may serve... You and we are tempted in different ways."
- p. 508: Steeply, kneading a bare shoulder: as much terrified as intrigued; Hoyne "an empty shell," his world "collapsed into one small bright point"; Willis's memo-phrase for the victims' eyes: "Empty of intent."
- p. 508: Marathe: "Terror seems part of the temptation for you"; the A.F.R. respects the weapon's power and does not "fool crazily about"; the stars pale toward false dawn, U.S. insects whirring jaggedly past, "making Marathe think of many windblown sparks."
Themes in this scene
- Entertainment and the Self: the strongest case yet that the Entertainment annihilates regardless of character — discipline, loyalty, twenty years of service all "collapsed into one small bright point"; "Empty of intent" names the end-state of pure passive pleasure.
- Addiction and Recovery: the casualty ward is described in pure addiction vocabulary — restraints, begging for a trailer like a fix, "drug-addicted newborn" eyes; Hoyne's white-knuckle sugar renunciation is precisely the self-willed abstinence AA distrusts, and it fails.
- Surveillance and Disguise: Marathe's verbatim dossier recitations (Hoyne's middle initial, the diabetes) display A.F.R. intelligence superiority; Steeply's femalia ("sleeveless skirt and different breasts") intrudes even into his grief.
Connections
Backward
- Direct, surely deliberate juxtaposition with scene 100: Roy Tony's "We done motherfucking surrendered our wills" (p. 506) against Hoyne's exemplary autonomous will (p. 507) — the book's two anthropologies of will side by side; self-control cannot do what surrender does.
Forward
- Continues scene 098 (pp. 489-491: the copies inventory, Flatto's density/holography theories) without a break; the serial resumes at scene 103 (pp. 528-530, the lethal-pleasure myths) — all one night of 30 Apr – 1 May YDAU.
- Hoyne's terminal viewing matches the medical attaché's household (scenes 007, 011, 014, 025, 028: the widening circle of viewers around the cartridge) and prefigures the federal dossier's own testing casualties — the penal-system "volunteers" lost to viewing attempts, and the Leavenworth Lance Corporal reporting the opening shot under near-lethal voltage (pp. 548-549, scene 107); the A.F.R.'s mirror program later prices each re-viewing at "one digit from the Subject's extremities" (scene 147, p. 727) — and his own father's MAS*H spiral (pp. 638ff).
- "Empty of intent" resonates forward to the narration's verdict on Hal — "inside Hal there's pretty much nothing at all, he knows" (p. 694, scene 135) — and the figurant/empty-eyes cluster, and backward to JOI's project of making an entertainment so compelling it would reverse Hal's retreat into blankness (the wraith's confession, pp. 838-839, scene 162).
- Marathe's "tempted in different ways" continues the serial's master argument (choosing one's temple, pp. 107-108; the spoon-fed death of pleasure, p. 318) and sets up his Gertraud confession in scene 103.
Notable passages
- p. 507: "He's in four-point restraints now. Nourishment through a tube. No desire or even basic survival-type will for anything other than more viewing." — the Entertainment's clinical end-state in three sentences.
- p. 507: "I watched this man put down all sugar and treats when he first got diagnosed. Just put them down and walked away... An American adult of exemplary self-control and discretion." — the will-of-steel case; anchor passage for entertainment-self.
- p. 508: "His world's as if it has collapsed into one small bright point. Inner world. Lost to us." — solipsism-by-pleasure.
- p. 508: Willis's coinage "'Empty of intent.' This appeared in a memo." — bureaucratic language meeting metaphysical horror.
What links here
- The A.F.R.'s Entertainment posture on the mountainside: Read-Only copies, testing losses, and "the theories of content irrelevant"
- The Entertainment: the A.F.R.'s Read-Only copies, testing, and losses
- The Office's own casualties — Hank Hoyne and the intern lost to the samizdat
- The cost of studying it — U.S.O.U.S.'s testing losses: the intern and Hank Hoyne
- The ecology of copies — Read-Only everywhere, no Master; the dissemination-as-weapon thesis
- U.S.O.U.S.'s own losses to the Entertainment: Hank Hoyne, "empty of intent"
- Why it's lethal — the open mechanism: holography-density, the p-terminal analogy, "empty of intent"
- Entertainment casualties
- Marathe & Steeply, losing people
- Marathe & Steeply, losing people — "With your sleeveless skirt and different…"
- Marathe on the temptation: Us of Québec have never felt this temptation
- Marathe on the temptation: Us of Québec have never felt this temptation — "Us of Québec’s cause, we have…"
- Roy Tony: we done surrendered our wills
- Roy Tony: we done surrendered our wills — "I done had to give four…"
- Roy Tony: we done surrendered our wills — "by this time Erdedy had both…"
- The Entertainment's casualties
- collapsed into one bright point: empty of intent
- collapsed into one bright point: empty of intent — "Willis, on the I/O night-shift, came…"
- four-point restraints: the Entertainment as terminal addiction
- four-point restraints: the Entertainment as terminal addiction — "Begging for just even a few…"
- the face that broadcasts without permission
- the iron will that walked away: self-control is no defense
- the iron will that walked away: self-control is no defense — "An American adult of exemplary self-control…"
- the self collapsed to a single bright point
- the self collapsed to a single bright point — "Willis, on the I/O night-shift, came…"