IJ study archive

DFW reads Up, Simba! (McCain's Promise) on This American Life (2000)

source

TL;DR

A This American Life segment ("Act Two: Sonny Takes a Fall") in which DFW reads edited excerpts of his Rolling Stone McCain-campaign piece — the 12 Monkeys, the bored network techs, and the South Carolina negative-ad spiral that sank McCain 2000. Radio production, host narration between excerpts, no interview with DFW himself. Canonical text: Up, Simba! (also in Consider the Lobster as "Up, Simba").

What's read

  • The press-bus taxonomy: techs handling "deep boredom" by going torpid, the essay's figure being an exhibit of lizards whose rock is not hot enough; the "12 Monkeys" — twelve interchangeable marquee pencils in immaculate wrinkle-free navy blazers with a uniform self-seriousness.
  • The negative-campaigning mechanics: Bush's ("the shrub's") push-poll offensive, McCain's "twist the truth like Clinton" react ad, the mutually-assured-negativity spiral, falling projected turnout, and the Falwell/Robertson "agents of intolerance" endgame.

Why it matters here

Politics done as entertainment-marketing analysis: the piece's real subject (sincerity vs. its salesmanship — is McCain's anti-candidate candor itself a marketing strategy?) is the irony/sincerity bind from E Unibus Pluram run on a campaign bus, and the voter-cynicism spiral matches the citizenship material in the ZDF 2003 interview (TV-ad money → corruption → disgust → disengagement).

Cross-references

  • Up, Simba!: canonical text.
  • E Unibus Pluram: packaged authenticity and audience-cynicism management.
  • ZDF 2003: the citizenship/TV-ads spiral.
  • WPR 2004: boredom as dread vector — the press-bus tedium is its political variant.
  • IJ connections: O.N.A.N. electoral satire (Gentle's CUSP as entertainment-candidate logic); marketing's capture of every sincere gesture.