IJ study archive

Marathe & Steeply: Gentle's manufactured ennemi commun — "There is the villain he saw…"

quote

There is the villain he saw you needed, all of you, to delay this splitting apart. To keep you together, the hating some other. Gentle is crazy in his head, but in this “fault of someone” he was correct in saying it. Un ennemi commun.

Context

The Reconfiguration reframed as domestic statecraft: Steeply calls it "self-preservation," Marathe calls it Gentle's manufacture of a needed villain — "the hating some other" as the glue "to delay this splitting apart," an "ennemi commun" built to keep a fracturing union together. This is the theme's account of why O.N.A.N. needs Canada as enemy: not territory or waste primarily, but the political utility of a common foe to a polity coming apart. Gentle "correct" that "someone is to blame" — the enemy is real politics, just aimed outward to hide an inward collapse.

In anthology