IJ study archive

Joelle cleaning; the Incandenza Thanksgiving — "Pre-Nuptial Agreement of Heaven and Hell—mordant…"

quote

Pre-Nuptial Agreement of Heaven and Hell—mordant, sophisticated, campy, hip, cynical, technically mind-bending; but cold, amateurish, hidden: no risk of empathy with the Job-like protagonist, whom she felt like the audience was induced to regard like somebody sitting atop a dunk-tank. The lampoons of ‘inverted’ genres: archly funny and sometimes insightful but with something provisional about them, like the finger-exercises of someone promising who refused to really sit down and play something to test that promise. Even as an undergrad Joelle’d been convinced that parodists were no better than camp-followers in ironic masks, satires usually the work of people with nothing new themselves to say.

Context

Joelle's verdict on the same "sub/inversion" period Hal anatomizes in 138, reached independently and landing harder: the lampoons as finger-exercises, parody as camp-following in an ironic mask. (The ref on this argument is n.306 — on no extraction roster, see Flags.) Hal watched Pre-Nuptial in 132 without comment; Joelle names what it does to its audience — induced contempt for a Job figure on a dunk-tank.

In anthology